The Sunday Nonsense

The Admiralty’s unlikely intelligence department

On Friday, Lloyd’s held its annual Remembrance ceremony, which is, without question, one of the most extraordinary things that happens in the Room, and I look forward to it every year.

For those who haven’t experienced it, representatives of the Armed Forces enter the underwriting Room, a Guard of Honour forms, wreaths are laid, and thousands of poppies fall through the enormous atrium. The Lutine Bell rings, the Last Post sounds, and for around half an hour the entire market falls silent.

I find it almost impossible to describe how moving it is. Here is a room normally occupied by people discussing premiums, catastrophe models and whether anybody has any capacity left, suddenly united in remembering people who gave absolutely everything.

And I think there’s something particularly wonderful about the Royal Navy’s presence, because I’ve discovered why the Admiralty had a rather good reason to be fond of Lloyd’s.

On the sly, we’ve been operating a global naval intelligence service Q herself would be pleased with.

I appreciate this is not traditionally how we describe the Lloyd’s Agency Network. But bear with me, because I think we’ve been underselling ourselves rather considerably.

For centuries, the shipping industry had a fairly significant problem.

You could send a ship halfway around the world carrying an enormously valuable cargo, but once it had departed, you had very little idea where it was, what had happened to it, or whether it was ever coming back.

Imagine sending several million pounds’ worth of goods overseas and being unable to track the delivery. I’ve had problems getting Evri to reliably deliver my socks, so I really feel I have skin in the game here.

But there was another difficulty.

Suppose you were a merchant who’d sent a ship to India to collect cotton, with instructions to bring it back to London. A few months later, you discovered that somebody in New York was prepared to pay considerably more for it.

Wonderful! You’d simply contact the captain and instruct him to change course.

Except you couldn’t.

There was no telephone, no email and certainly no WhatsApp group entitled Cotton Logistics, in which the captain could ignore your increasingly urgent messages while posting photographs of the sunset.

Once the ship sailed, the instructions sailed with it. But it’s time to be honest here: we both know what’s coming…

Lloyd’s did something rather clever.

In 1811, the market established its Agency Network, appointing representatives in ports around the world to gather information about shipping. Over time, Lloyd’s also developed signal stations, where ships could identify themselves to observers ashore using flags and other signals.

The information travelled back to London, where owners, merchants and underwriters could discover where ships had been seen.

But the truly ingenious part was that communication could work the other way.

A shipowner could send instructions through Lloyd’s to be passed to a vessel when it appeared off one of the signal stations.

Imagine that. A captain who’d left England months earlier could discover that his employer had changed his mind and wanted the cargo delivered somewhere completely different.

I suspect the captains weren’t necessarily delighted.

But commercially, this was revolutionary. Merchants could respond to changing prices and opportunities rather than being imprisoned by decisions made months earlier.

And I think we can reasonably suggest that helping Britain communicate with its enormous merchant fleet gave the country a rather substantial advantage in world trade.

All accomplished with agents, signal towers, telescopes and people waving flags at ships.

The nineteenth-century equivalent of a global communications platform, with considerably less expenditure on software licences.

But here’s where the story becomes even more interesting.

The Admiralty realised that if Lloyd’s were already keeping track of and reporting the movements of ships, they could also report the movements of warships.

In 1908, the Admiralty even produced a book called Block Sketches of War Vessels, essentially a rather serious naval version of I-Spy, and asked Lloyd’s to distribute it to shipowners and encourage their captains to report any warships they spotted.

Imagine that. The Royal Navy, with its battleships, cruisers and enough guns to make even the most major disagreements rather conclusive, was asking an insurance market to help it keep an eye on the world’s oceans.

I just think what our market has contributed to the world knows no bounds.

Lloyd’s had an extraordinary network of people who knew what was happening in ports and at sea.

And when war came, information like that mattered enormously.

Britain depended upon ships to bring food, fuel, raw materials and countless other necessities across dangerous oceans. The Navy had to protect those routes, while merchant sailors continued making voyages despite the threat of mines, submarines and enemy warships.

Knowing where vessels had been seen, which routes were dangerous and where ships might need assistance wasn’t simply a commercial advantage any more.

It could help protect the people aboard them.

And those ships weren’t just entries in a shipping register.

They were full of men whose families were waiting for them to come home.

A wife waiting for her husband. Children waiting for their father. Parents waiting for news of a son.

Suddenly, knowing where a ship was had become about something considerably more important than the price of cotton.

Which brings me back to Friday.

During the First World War, nearly 2,500 men from Lloyd’s had entered military service before conscription was even introduced. More than 200 members of our market lost their lives.

They weren’t simply names in a record. They were people who had walked into Lloyd’s, worked alongside friends and colleagues, and had families waiting for them too.

Some never came home.

And on Friday, as the Armed Forces stood in the Room, the poppies fell, the Lutine Bell rang and the Last Post sounded, we remembered them alongside all the others who gave their lives.

I’ve always loved the extraordinary history of the Lloyd’s market. Its ships, its underwriters, its worldwide network and its remarkable habit of finding solutions to problems nobody else has thought to solve.

But I think there’s something especially moving about discovering that the same network which helped merchants find their ships also helped Britain understand what was happening at sea when the country needed that knowledge most.

Because behind every ship was a crew.

And behind every sailor was somebody waiting for news.

For centuries, people came to Lloyd’s hoping to discover whether a ship had arrived safely.

On Friday, we remembered those who never did.

Have a good week,

Rob