On Wednesday, the 1986 Lloyd’s building turns forty. I’ve spent longer than is normal, or even advisable, wondering how to celebrate this, because I’m not sure what the etiquette is for congratulating a building, but we both know I can’t let it go un marked – so I guess an increasingly daft email on a Sunday will have to suffice.
Opposite the executive suite reception hangs an oil painting of the Queen (original version) opening the building on 18 November 1986. Everyone is in their finest suit, the television cameras are rolling, and everybody is in awe of the magnificent new Room. I walk past that painting rather more often than is strictly necessary, occasionally pretending I have legitimate business in that part of the building, but really I’m just there to chat to the waiters and stand in the Adam room.
Five years earlier, the Queen Mother had visited Lime Street and pulled a lever which poured half a tonne of concrete into one of the columns to mark the start of construction. Other members of the Royal Family cut ribbons. Ours operates heavy construction machinery, and there’s a dedication to commemorate her at the entrance to Tower 1 on the left hand side as you go up the stairs.
She predicted that the City “may well argue” about the building.
She was right. People argued, until 2011 when it became the youngest building ever given Grade I listing, which is the architectural equivalent of being made a saint while you’re still alive. I like this as a brilliant example of British compromise. Basically: we can’t agree if we like the thing, so we’ll make it illegal to change it. Superb, though it worries me when real life events are more nonsensical than the Sunday Nonsense itself.
I adore the building. You know I adore the building. Some of you have been marched around it by me for sixty minutes and lived to tell the tale. I understand a number of you have even made a full recovery, so I remain on hand to take you round again.
But this week I’ve been thinking about another painting. It doesn’t contain a Queen, and instead depicts a rather unfortunate incident involving forty men in a boat that was never supposed to accommodate anything like that number.
To explain, you need to come back with me to 1802.
At the beginning of the nineteenth century, Britain had a problem. Ships were being wrecked along the coast, and people were drowning in full view of those on shore because ordinary fishing boats couldn’t survive the heavy seas to rescue them.
Proper lifeboats though had already been invented. What nobody had worked out was who should pay for them. Parliament considered the matter and concluded that lifeboats should be left to “private enterprise”. A tremendously generous position to adopt when it’s somebody else’s money. I have written before that politicians have always been useless when it comes to insurance, and I stand by it.
Fortunately, private enterprise includes Lloyd’s.
So in May 1802, John Julius Angerstein proposed that the Room establish a fund to provide lifeboats along the coast. The underwriters allocated £2,000, and Lloyd’s became the foundation of the early lifeboat movement, decades before the RNLI was formed.
Angerstein was also an art collector whose paintings became the founding collection of the National Gallery. This is convenient for me, because we’re already discussing our second painting and I haven’t even got to the inevitable shipwreck yet.
In 1824, a group of marine insurers at Lloyd’s agreed to fund a lifeboat for Douglas on the Isle of Man. She was twenty-nine feet long, built in Sunderland, and cost £112. I hate to be one of those people who moans about rising prices, but for context that would now buy you just fourteen pints at The Jampot. As you can probably tell by the quality of the writing, I get through more than that while creating a single issue of The Nonsense.
Anyway, they called their lifeboat True Blue.
Six years later, she would earn every penny, and considerably more than fourteen pints.
On Friday 19 November 1830, the mail steamer St George arrived at Douglas from Liverpool and anchored in the bay. Overnight, the weather deteriorated into a violent storm. At about five the next morning her anchor chain gave way, and she was driven onto St Mary’s Rock, which she struck violently and began filling with water.
Sir William Hillary, the founder of what would become the RNLI, learned of the disaster and went straight down to the harbour. He was almost sixty years old and couldn’t swim, which strikes me as two perfectly reasonable excuses for remaining at home. Hillary evidently disagreed.
With his coxswain Isaac Vondy and sixteen other men, he launched True Blue into the storm.
The sea was so violent that even the captain of the St George itself begged them not to attempt the rescue, convinced they would all be killed. They ignored him and backed the lifeboat into the narrow gap between the wreck and the rocks.
Almost immediately, everything went wrong. The rudder was smashed off, six of the ten oars were broken or lost, and waves threw Hillary and several others overboard. Hillary, who you’ll recall couldn’t swim, grabbed a rope hanging from the ship and held on until he could be hauled aboard with no fewer than six broken ribs.
The boat was now trapped. The ship’s fallen mast blocked their escape, and for nearly two hours the men struggled to cut away the wreckage while the storm raged around them.
Eventually, they cleared a passage and all twenty-two men from the St George climbed into the lifeboat.
Which meant there were now forty men in a twenty-nine-foot wooden boat, with four functioning oars, no rudder, and buckets borrowed from the wreck to keep themselves afloat.
They cut the cable holding them to the ship. The lifeboat itself then struck the reef, filled with water, struck it again, and was finally swept over the rocks by the waves. Somehow, she emerged on the sheltered side, where two other boats came out to help her reach the shore.
All forty men survived.
A fortnight ago, I told you that I couldn’t find the names of the 170 people Lloyd’s sheltered during the Blitz. I still can’t.
But while researching this week’s story, I found a contemporary account of the St George rescue. It names four men who went out in the True Blue, including Hillary and Isaac Vondy, and then lists the boatmen.
William Connor. John Inch. Thomas Carran. Thomas Cannell. William Gill. George Thompson. Henry Clagne. Robert Kewley. Richard Harvey. Philip Cottley. John Callow. Richard Cowle.
And then, at the end of the list, are three words…
“And another boatman“.
The account says eighteen men went out, but only sixteen are named. Which means one gets only those three words, and the other doesn’t even get that.
Two years later, Hillary had a stone castle built on St Mary’s Rock so that anyone wrecked there again would have somewhere to shelter. It’s called the Tower of Refuge, and it’s still there. I like the idea that, having nearly died rescuing people from a rock, he decided the rock itself needed improving.
And somebody painted the rescue. The Wreck of the St George is an oil painting in the Manx national collection.
Which brings us back to the painting opposite the executive suite.
One shows the Queen opening our magnificent building on 18 November 1986. The other shows forty men fighting for their lives in a wooden boat on 20 November 1830 paid for by the market she opened.
Two paintings, separated by almost exactly 156 years.
On Wednesday, we’ll celebrate forty years of a building whose history we’ve carefully preserved, right down to the afternoon the Queen Mother poured half a tonne of concrete into one of its columns.
And on Friday, it will be 196 years since eighteen men climbed into a little wooden boat that the insurance market had paid for, and brought twenty-two strangers home.
We know the lifeboat cost £112. We know six of its oars broke, and that Sir William Hillary broke six ribs. We even know how much concrete the Queen Mother poured into a column 151 years later.
But we don’t know the names of two of the men who went out into that storm, and helped give twenty-two strangers the chance to live the rest of their lives.
I wish we did.
And another boatman.
Have a good week,
Rob
P.S. Lloyd’s is opening the building to the market from 18 to 25 November for an anniversary exhibition called Looking Inside Out. Do go, if only because it’s a rare chance to visit without having to endure one of my tedious guided tours.
